Most founders pitch press the same way: one email, blasted to everyone at once, hoping someone bites.
There's a sharper move almost nobody uses, and it's behind one of our biggest press hits. Instead of spraying your story everywhere, you give it to the one reporter who fits best, before anyone else sees it. It's called an exclusive.
Quick context so you know I'm not theorizing. I've sent thousands of cold emails, written hundreds of unique pitches, and landed 200-plus placements in outlets like the New York Times, the BBC, and TechCrunch, with no media connections and no agency. So when I tell you how press actually works, it's from reps, not theory.
One of those wins was an exclusive we gave to Business Insider. I didn't blast the story everywhere. I offered it to them first, and only them. They ran it. A story that could have died as a two-line blurb somewhere became a real Business Insider feature.
Why does an exclusive work so well? Because you're not asking the journalist for a favor. You're giving them one.
Think about it from the reporter's side. Their entire job is to publish something their competitors don't have.
A story that ten other outlets are running at the same time is worth almost nothing to them. The exact same story, offered to them and only them, is suddenly worth their time. You've handed them a small scoop.
I learned this the hard way. In my early days, before Filteroff, I'd blast the same generic press release to every contact page I could find. It went nowhere.
What changed everything was learning to pitch one specific reporter a story built for them. An exclusive is just the strongest version of that. You give one reporter the whole story, and nobody else gets it.
So the exclusive flips it. Instead of "please cover us," you're saying "I'll give you this before anyone else." You're not begging anymore. You're making a trade.
Here's how to actually run it.
Pick the right journalist, not just the right outlet. Your real press list is every reporter who covers your niche, and it's bigger than you think.
It can span a hundred outlets, and sometimes twenty reporters at a single one. What matters is whether a reporter actually covers your space, not how big their outlet is.
The exclusive is choosing the single best-fit reporter to go first. The one whose beat is your space and whose readers are your customers. For us, that story belonged with a reporter at Business Insider.
Lead with the word exclusive. Put it right in the subject line so the value is obvious before they open. "Exclusive: the specific news." Say exactly what the news is, right there in the subject.
Give a real deadline and honor it. The deal is simple. They get it first, and you don't shop it elsewhere until they've run it or passed. If you break that, you burn the relationship, so don't.
Have a fallback ready. If they pass, fine. You take it to the next reporter on your list and offer them the exclusive instead. The story didn't lose value. It just found the right home.
One more thing that makes or breaks it. Never offer the same exclusive to two outlets at once.
An exclusive is like applying early decision to a college. You only get to commit to one. Promise it to two and you've broken the whole deal.
And reporters talk. If a journalist finds out the scoop you promised was also sitting in three other inboxes, you don't just lose that story. You lose them for every story after it.
That's your reputation gone, and in press your reputation is the entire game. It's a cheap move, and people remember it.
You told someone this one was theirs. The only way that works is if it's true.
A lot of founders worry an exclusive means giving up reach. It's the opposite. One real feature in the outlet that matters beats ten reprints of a press release nobody reads.
And once that first outlet runs it, the story has validation. Other reporters see it ran somewhere credible, and the follow-on coverage gets easier, not harder.
The exclusive isn't the end of your press run. It's how you start it.
The mistake most founders make is treating their news like it's precious and assuming everyone should want it. Reporters don't owe you coverage. But they do want scoops. An exclusive is just you packaging your news as the thing they actually want.
One thing to try this week: take the next piece of news you have, a launch, a hire, a number, a milestone, and instead of spraying it everywhere, pick the one reporter who fits best and offer it to them first. Watch how different the response is when you lead with "exclusive."
What's a piece of news you're sitting on right now that you've been too nervous to pitch? Hit reply and tell me what it is. Sometimes the angle is more obvious from the outside.
Zach
P.S. Figuring out which journalist to send that exclusive to is the part most founders get stuck on. That's exactly what I built PressPitch for. It finds the right reporters for your story and writes the pitch for you. Free for 7 days, no credit card. presspitchai.com
Know a founder who needs press? Share this newsletter to get free pitch templates, journalist contacts, press angles, and a strategy call with me.
I partnered with MarketBeat! Check them out below.
The robotics trade is starting to move. Surgical systems, warehouse automation, machine vision, and smart factories are turning “Physical AI” into real business. MarketBeat’s 7 Stocks to Buy Before the Robotics Revolution reveals 7 companies positioned before Wall Street piles in. Reveal The 7 Stocks.